Clients' Testimonials

Sarah Underhill was our real estate agent in the sale of our old house and the purchase of our new house, in the MountPleasant/Eglinton area of Toronto, in July of 2006. Sarah was always available on the phone and in person whenever we needed her advice. We found her to be extremely knowledgeable about the real estate market and we are convinced that we were able to secure deals on both houses that exceeded our expectations because of this. We always feel that we receive the best possible care in our dealings with Sarah and wouldn’t hesitate to use her again when the time comes to move. We have recommended her to all our friends.

Ann Sidon

Sarah exemplifies the qualities of a dedicated, "customer is #1" real estate professional. In spite of the ultra-hot real estate market, Sarah showed infinite patience with me, giving me undivided attention and helping me find my dream home. Thank you Sarah!

Garry Chan

Sarah’s negotiating skills with the buying broker were exceptional – she was patient, calm and above all, confident in her appraisal of the condo. Her poise got us our price.

Janet Chant

I worked with Sarah to sell my house in the spring of 2009 and she went above and beyond every step of the way in the selling process. From providing quality insights on the market, to creating top-notch marketing materials, to ensuring my house looked perfect the day it was listed, Sarah helped me get a price that was well beyond my expectations. Throughout the closing process Sarah was very attentive to details and always on top of everything. I would strongly recommend Sarah, and would never buy or sell a house in the Toronto area without her help.

Kelly Pedersen

Sarah was wonderful to work with when we were making the move from the burbs to a downtown condo. She very quickly identified our needs and provided a steady stream of appropriate listings. I know we were very particular clients but Sarah persisted and found us a perfect new home, in our desired location and price range. I would not hesitate to recommend her! Thanks, Sarah!

Moreen Murray

As first time home buyer's we especially appreciated Sarah! She guided us through every step of the home buying process, all the while taking the time to explain the pros and cons of each decision and directing us to the correct resources. We never felt pressured and appreciated the experienced advice she gave. Sarah is a terrific real estate agent and great to work with!

Radhika Kakkar

We met Sarah about 3 years ago when we were a newly married couple looking for a condo in downtown Toronto. Sarah stayed with us as our needs changed and our search evolved into houses, and this past spring, we successfully bought a gorgeous home in Toronto for a great price. Throughout this very long period Sarah demonstrated strong knowledge of the real estate industry and gave us honest and wise advice. She kept our current and future needs in mind at all times and always provided a stable sounding board for our ideas and thoughts. We highly recommend Sarah Underhill as a Real Estate Agent for these reasons. Thanks again Sarah!

Ram and Nisha Naguleswaran

Sarah helped us with the sale of our first house and was instrumental in securing us another agent’s help when we decided to buy in another city. As anyone can appreciate, the first time you sell a house is nerve wracking and stressful. Through her special attention to detail and blend of professionalism, and her market savvy approach, she was able to help us get our house ready to sell in a short time, secure a buyer and a sale price far above what we expected. She really came through and totally impressed us and we would have no hesitation recommending her to anyone!

Rob and Charlotte McGarry

We were just starting to think about buying our first house when we met Sarah. From the start, we thought that she was the right agent for us and it didn't take long for our first impressions to be confirmed. She was on the ball, focused, no nonsense and answered all our pesky first homebuyer questions in a way that was both knowledgeable and friendly. We had a list of things that we wanted and she found us a house that fit our needs perfectly. We have been recommending her to friends and strangers and a few years down the road when it comes time to sell this house, Sarah is the only agent we're going to call.

S Davidson

We have worked with Sarah on two separate occasions over the past few years. She helped us buy and sell our first condo and to acquire our current home. We have always been so very impressed by Sarah because she brings a unique mix of strong market experience and a human touch. Throughout both the buying and selling experience it was always clear that Sarah was looking out for our best interests and she showed incredible patience when helping us find the right home. I never hesitate to recommend Sarah to my friends and family.

Sean Van Doorselaer

I first met Sarah as a selling agent for an open house I dropped into a few years back. I didn't have an agent at the time, but instantly liked Sarah and after talking with her that day, I started getting her show me properties. I bought and sold my first condo with Sarah and am back with her now, in the market for a house with new husband and baby on the way. Sarah is a dream agent... she is straight up without being pushy; professional and personable; well presented, organized and quick to respond to any queries... and I seem to have a lot!! I have consistently found her advice to be sound and her approach has allowed me to go through the buying and selling process with comfort and ease.

Trish Hay

"Working with Sarah was a fantastic experience from start to finish. She was a true partner in the sale of my home, offering expert staging advice and a smart pricing strategy that led to multiple offers—even in a softer market. Sarah connected me with top-notch third-party professionals who helped prepare my home for listing, and she negotiated an outstanding deal on my behalf. Throughout the entire process, she kept in close communication, ensuring everything stayed on track through to closing. Beyond her deep knowledge and professionalism, Sarah is a pleasure to work with—straightforward, diligent, and genuinely enjoyable to be around. She worked tirelessly with my best interests in mind, and I couldn’t have asked for a better agent."

-Krista B.

"Sarah is a very genuine, trustworthy, and knowledgeable agent. She puts 100% into her work. From getting to know your property, helping to stage and market it - she misses no details. She has a wonderful social media team, brings energy and enthusiasm to each interaction and is an overall pleasure to work with. We're lucky to have her."

-Ramzi D.

"I am a huge fan of Sarah. She has sold two homes for me and helped me purchase one, and I can say quite confidently that she is the best Realtor I have ever worked with. Sarah goes way above and beyond when helping you sell your home. She provides invaluable guidance on what to do, offers market comparables, and gives precise pricing advice. Sarah's support doesn't stop there; she helps with decluttering, puts excess items into storage, and stages your home beautifully. Her marketing skills are top-notch, creating clever social video posts and beautiful pamphlets. She also hosts the most amazing and thoughtful open houses, like the time she had little Easter baskets over Easter weekend. If you're looking for a Realtor who truly cares and goes the extra mile, I highly recommend Sarah."

-Nicole C.

“Sarah has been my realtor for both the purchase and sale of multiple houses for me. Her knowledge of the housing market, professionalism and wonderful personality make her a trusted real estate advisor. I highly recommend Sarah - she is an absolute delight to work with.”

-Danelle B.

“It has been truly a pleasure to have Sarah as our RE agent. Trustworthy, experienced and hardworking; a superstar agent!!! Not only are we happy with the price and advice we had received but we also appreciated her support to make our experience pleasant and worry free. Sarah sold a house on our street and our Neighbours said that she was awesome. Indeed she is!!”

-Lina P.

“Sarah and her team did an excellent job of assessing, staging and marketing my property within the current market. As a result we sold over asking in three days. I would highly recommend Sarah and her team to anyone looking to sell or purchase a home. She is highly professional, easy to work with and gets stellar results.”

-Martin T.

“We have purchased three properties and sold 1 through Sarah. Sarah is very honest and transparent with her views. Her style of communication is very authentic which helped us immensely. As immigrants all those years ago trying to buy our first property, we were able to rely on Sarah 100% for good advice. She is never pushy with her POV even when she has a strong one. She balances that with ensuring she gives you more information than you need to help make the right decision. She is like family to us now.”

-Amit K.